AFDARAالعربيةSign in

Home / Resources / Ponte Morandi, 2018

Asset Management Review · No. 05

Ponte Morandi, 2018

The steel nobody could see. A reliability and asset management reading of the case, with five practical checks for owners of ageing structures.

AFDARA · Version 1.0 · November 2026 · 5-page PDF, free

Summary

On 14 August 2018 about 200 m of the Polcevera viaduct in Genoa, Italy, collapsed during a rainstorm, killing 43 people. In the 2020 report summarised by Italian court-appointed experts, corrosion at the upper part of the Genoa-side south stay of pier 9, hidden inside concrete, was identified as the triggering failure mechanism; the broader collapse sequence and responsibility findings remained subject to evidence, judgment and appeal. A project to strengthen the stays had been designed but never built. In the July 2026 first-instance judgment, the Tribunal of Genoa reportedly found the collapse foreseeable and preventable and convicted 32 defendants; the written reasoning and all convictions remained subject to appeal. We review the case with a bow-tie view, a contributing-factor map, RCM and an ISO 55001:2024 lens, and turn it into five checks.

This brief describes findings of court-appointed experts and a first-instance verdict. The verdict is subject to appeal; nothing here assigns individual responsibility.

Key findings

  1. Court experts identified corrosion at the top of the Genoa-side south stay of pier 9 as the triggering mechanism.
  2. Inspections were judged insufficient and unreliable for the stay steel; no direct examination was made at the critical point.
  3. A stay retrofit for piers 9 and 10 was designed from 2015 but never started.
  4. Available monitoring was described as substantially qualitative and limited in coverage.

If your inspection method cannot see the failure mode, you do not have an inspection. You have a ritual.

Five practical checks

  1. Can your inspection see the failure mode? For each critical element, state the failure mechanism and show that the inspection method can detect it.
  2. Treat unknown as degraded Where condition cannot be established, apply interim measures until it can.
  3. Learn from sister assets A defect on one element is evidence about all similar elements.
  4. Put dates on deferred strengthening Every approved but unbuilt repair needs an owner, a date and an interim restriction.
  5. Independent challenge Make sure someone outside the operating chain reviews the condition of critical structures and can stop operation.
Question for your team

Which critical part of your asset can you not see inside, and how do you know it is sound?

Common questions

What happened in the Ponte Morandi bridge collapse?

On 14 August 2018 about 200 m of the Polcevera viaduct in Genoa, Italy, collapsed during a rainstorm, killing 43 people In the 2020 report summarised by Italian court-appointed experts, corrosion at the upper part of the Genoa-side south stay of pier 9, hidden inside concrete, was identified as the triggering failure mechanism; the broader collapse sequence and responsibility findings remained subject to evidence, judgment and appeal.

What are the main asset management lessons from the Ponte Morandi bridge collapse?

Court experts identified corrosion at the top of the Genoa-side south stay of pier 9 as the triggering mechanism. Inspections were judged insufficient and unreliable for the stay steel; no direct examination was made at the critical point. A stay retrofit for piers 9 and 10 was designed from 2015 but never started. Available monitoring was described as substantially qualitative and limited in coverage.

What can a site check today?

The paper gives five checks: Can your inspection see the failure mode; Treat unknown as degraded; Learn from sister assets; Put dates on deferred strengthening; Independent challenge. If your inspection method cannot see the failure mode, you do not have an inspection. You have a ritual.

This page summarises the full paper. The PDF adds the event sequence, a bow-tie view, a contributing-factor map, an RCM table, an ISO 55001:2024 lens, illustrative indicators and the full list of sources. It is a practitioner interpretation from public sources, not legal or engineering advice.

More from the Asset Management Review